What Bugs Me
Wooden poles not a long-term solution for stopping soil erosion at Changi Beach

STOMPer Cow sense thinks more needs to be done to prevent soil erosion at Changi Beach Park. He suggests building a breakwater instead of driving wooden poles into the sea bed.

He says:

"Parts of the beach are affected by soil erosion and even the tree roots are exposed.

"To stop the soil erosion, a row of wooden poles have been driven into the seabed in order to contain the soil erosion.

"This beach is assaulted by the waves 24/7 and eventually the wooden poles will give way.

"To stop the soil erosion, a concrete breakwater is necessary as the waves will keep pounding on the coast and cause more trees to topple over."

  Click on thumbnails for larger image
Keywords:  beach soil erosion
Enraged
4%
Shiok!
12%
LOL!
36%
So sad
28%
Sure or not?
4%
Bochup
16%
Rated  
  by 1 STOMPer(s).      
1969 Views
5 comments
Leon123456 said   on 29 Oct, 2011   Report as offensive  
not teak wood lah.. Teak wood so expensive..

temporary fixed lah.
pyjstein said   on 29 Oct, 2011   Report as offensive  
@ boyan619: "this wooden poles is a Teak Wood"

For info, those poles are Bakau wood. They are used for the temporary stabilization of unstable soils, slopes & embankments -- in which case, they are known as bakau piles (the process is called bakau piling). Bakau wood is harvested from Rhizophora mangrove trees, & is resistant to rotting during prolonged immersion in water or wet soil.

* Photo of Bakau Piles: http://www.ramungan.com/products.htm
* PUB's Specification for Bakau Piles: http://goo.gl/jhrqV

* Bakau Trees: http://www.naturia.per.sg/buloh/plants/rhizophora.htm

Teak wood is very much more expensive, & thus generally not "wasted" as piling material.
boyan619 said   on 28 Oct, 2011   Report as offensive  
this wooden poles is a Teak Wood
pyjstein said   on 28 Oct, 2011   Report as offensive  
All these sandy beaches along the southern coast are reclaimed land, & largely with smuggled sand -- ie. at the erosional expense of sand-originating countries ... what utter irony. In effect, S'pore's technocrats are working against nature, as large expanses of fine-sand shores are unlikely to naturally occur here, given the currents & geomorphology of the S'pore Straits.

Those beach-reinforcing bakau piles have been at Changi Beach for sometime now. However, a concrete breakwater or other artificial shore-revetments are merely temporary stop-gap measures.

The relevant authorities might wish to look into more sustainable long-term solutions, such as replanting native seaward-tolerant mangrove tree species (eg. Avicennia, Sonneratia) along the shoreline & nearshore. When established, the tree roots & associated coastal community not only serve to grip onto the coastal floor, but also help dissipate wave energy, as well as encourage sediment deposition at suitable spots.
ocliff70 said   on 28 Oct, 2011   Report as offensive  
What a waste of money to reclaim the land if like that.